Mr. Altig’s Overview of the Wonderful Dharma of the Lotus Sutra

I. Introduction

A. The Lotus Sūtra: Pinnacle of Mahayana Teaching

The Saddharma Puṇḍarīka Sūtra, or Lotus Sūtra, stands as a monument in the landscape of Mahayana Buddhist literature. Revered across East Asia and beyond, it is celebrated for its profound doctrines, dramatic narrative style, and its transformative message of universal liberation.¹ Often characterized by its visionary scenes and complex parables ⁴, the Sūtra’s core teachings revolve around the concept of the One Vehicle (Ekayāna), asserting that the various paths presented in Buddhist teachings are ultimately skillful means (upāya) leading all sentient beings toward the single goal of perfect Buddhahood.¹ It radically affirms the potential for enlightenment inherent within all beings, regardless of their capacity, status, or past actions.¹

B. Chapter 15: A Turning Point – Entering the Essential Teaching

Within the twenty-eight chapters of the Lotus Sūtra, the fifteenth chapter, commonly titled “Emerging from the Earth” (Jūji-yujuppon), represents a crucial pivot point.⁷ Its significance is particularly emphasized in the interpretive frameworks of major East Asian Buddhist schools, such as Tendai (Tiantai) and Nichiren Buddhism. These traditions typically divide the Sūtra into two main sections: the “trace” or “theoretical” teaching (shakumon, chapters 1-14) and the “origin” or “essential” teaching (honmon, chapters 15-28).⁵ The theoretical teaching is understood as presenting truths adapted to the capacities of the listeners, focusing on the historical Shakyamuni Buddha and the path to enlightenment through various expedient means. Chapter 15 dramatically inaugurates the essential teaching, shifting the focus towards revealing the Buddha’s fundamental, original nature—his enlightenment in the inconceivably remote past—and his eternal, ongoing activity in the world.⁷ This chapter, therefore, serves as the threshold into the Sūtra’s deepest revelations concerning the nature of Buddhahood, time, and the mission entrusted to specific disciples.

C. Report Aims and Structure

This report aims to provide a comprehensive scholarly analysis of Chapter 15 of the Lotus Sūtra, addressing the specific points raised in the user query. Drawing upon textual evidence and established interpretations, it will explore the chapter’s narrative progression, the roles of the key interlocutors Shakyamuni Buddha and Maitreya Bodhisattva, the identity and symbolism of the Bodhisattvas who emerge from the earth, the perplexing teaching that challenges conventional understanding, the function of Maitreya’s analogy, the crucial role of doubt and inquiry in the Buddhist path, the diverse interpretations offered by different Buddhist traditions, and the profound philosophical implications arising from this pivotal chapter. The subsequent sections will systematically address each of these facets, synthesizing textual data and interpretive insights to illuminate the richness and depth of “Emerging from the Earth.”

II. The Unfolding Drama: Narrative Summary of Chapter 15

The fifteenth chapter of the Lotus Sūtra unfolds with theatrical grandeur, marking a significant shift in the Sūtra’s exposition. The scene is set during the magnificent “Ceremony in the Air,” where Shakyamuni Buddha is preaching from within a jeweled stupa suspended in space, alongside the ancient Buddha Prabhūtaratna (Many Treasures).¹⁴

A. The Vow of Visiting Bodhisattvas

The chapter commences as innumerable Bodhisattvas Mahasattvas, great beings dedicated to enlightenment, who have journeyed from countless other world-systems to hear the Buddha’s discourse, step forward.² Filled with devotional fervor and recognizing the importance of the teaching, they collectively make a solemn vow. They pledge that after Shakyamuni Buddha enters parinirvāṇa (final extinction), they will remain in this sahā world—the world characterized by suffering and endurance—to diligently protect, uphold, read, recite, copy, explain, and propagate the Lotus Sūtra for the benefit of future beings.² Their intention is noble, expressing the universal Bodhisattva aspiration to save all beings.

B. Shakyamuni’s Refusal

In a move that startles the assembly, Shakyamuni Buddha immediately halts these visiting Bodhisattvas.⁷ He declares, “Good men, stop! There is no need for you to protect and uphold this sutra”.¹⁶ He explains that this sahā world, his own domain of teaching, already possesses a vast multitude of Bodhisattvas Mahasattvas perfectly capable of carrying out this crucial task after his passing.⁷ This unexpected refusal creates dramatic tension and signals that a significant revelation is imminent. Some interpretations suggest a compassionate motive behind this refusal: Shakyamuni wished for his own original disciples, those intrinsically connected to the sahā world, to gain the immense merit associated with propagating the Sūtra in the difficult ages to come, rather than allowing Bodhisattvas from other realms to undertake the task.¹⁶

C. The Earth Trembles and Splits

As Shakyamuni finishes speaking, a cosmic event of immense proportions occurs. The very earth of the thousand-millionfold sahā world system begins to tremble violently and then splits open.² This dramatic manifestation underscores the gravity and world-altering nature of what is about to be revealed.

D. Emergence of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth

From the fissures rent in the earth, an almost unbelievable sight unfolds: “immeasurable thousands, ten thousands, millions” ¹⁴—a boundless host—of Bodhisattvas Mahasattvas simultaneously well up from below.² Their numbers are described as exceeding calculation, simile, or parable, equaling the sands of sixty thousand Ganges Rivers, each leader bringing retinues of comparable size.⁷ These are the Bodhisattvas of the Earth (jiyu no bosatsu).

Their appearance is magnificent: their bodies are “golden in hue,” adorned with the thirty-two major marks of a Buddha, and they radiate an “immeasurable brightness”.² The text specifies that they had previously been dwelling in the realm of empty space beneath the sahā world, and upon hearing Shakyamuni’s voice, they emerged.²

E. The Four Leaders

Leading this immense congregation are four principal Bodhisattvas, described as the foremost leaders and guiding teachers among the group.⁹ They are named Superior Practices (Viśiṣṭacāritra), Boundless Practices (Anantacāritra), Pure Practices (Viśuddhacāritra), and Firmly Established Practices (Supratiṣṭhitacāritra).⁷ These figures hold significant symbolic weight in later interpretations.

F. Paying Homage and Inquiry

Having emerged, these countless Bodhisattvas ascend into the air, proceeding to the Jeweled Stupa where Shakyamuni and Prabhūtaratna are seated.¹⁴ They reverently bow their heads at the feet of the two Buddhas and also pay homage to the countless emanations of Shakyamuni seated under jeweled trees throughout space.¹⁴ The four leaders then address Shakyamuni on behalf of the multitude, respectfully inquiring about his well-being: “Is the World Honored One comfortable, with few illnesses, few worries? In teaching and converting living beings, can you do so without fatigue and weariness?”.¹⁴ Shakyamuni reassures them, affirming his well-being and stating that the beings he teaches are readily converted because they have received his instruction for ages past and planted good roots with previous Buddhas.¹⁴

G. Maitreya’s Perplexity

Witnessing this unprecedented event—the emergence of such a vast and magnificent host of Bodhisattvas previously unknown to the assembly—causes profound astonishment and perplexity among all present, including high-ranking Bodhisattvas like Maitreya.⁷ Maitreya Bodhisattva, recognized as a leading disciple and the future Buddha, perceives the thoughts and doubts arising in the minds of the assembly and wishes also to resolve his own confusion.¹⁴ He steps forward as the spokesperson, asking Shakyamuni about the origins of these Bodhisattvas: Who are they? Where have they come from? What causes and conditions brought them together? Who was their teacher?.⁷

H. Shakyamuni’s Initial Reply and Maitreya’s Doubt

Shakyamuni Buddha replies directly, stating that these innumerable Bodhisattvas are, in fact, his own original disciples, whom he personally taught and converted, awakening their aspiration for enlightenment, since the long distant past.⁷ This assertion is the crux of the chapter’s central paradox.

Maitreya, voicing the logical impasse felt by all, respectfully questions the Buddha further.⁷ He points out the apparent contradiction: Shakyamuni had left his princely home, practiced austerities, and attained supreme perfect enlightenment near the city of Gaya relatively recently—a ministry spanning only some forty-odd years.⁷ How, Maitreya asks, could the Buddha possibly have raised such an immeasurable multitude of highly accomplished Bodhisattvas, who have clearly been practicing for countless eons, in such a short period?.⁷ He uses the famous analogy of the young father and aged sons to illustrate the seeming impossibility (elaborated in Section VI). Recognizing that this point could cause doubt among believers in the future, Maitreya earnestly beseeches the Buddha to explain this inconceivable matter clearly for the benefit of all.⁷ The chapter concludes with this unresolved question hanging in the air, perfectly setting the stage for the profound revelation of the Buddha’s true lifespan and original enlightenment in the following chapter, “Life Span of the Thus Come One”.⁷

The very structure of this narrative serves a profound pedagogical purpose. The sequence—rejecting help from expected quarters, the dramatic emergence of unexpected agents from an unexpected place, and the resulting intellectual crisis voiced by a leading disciple—functions to deliberately disrupt the audience’s conventional framework. By presenting a scenario that defies ordinary logic and chronology, the narrative shatters preconceived notions about the Buddha’s identity and the nature of time. This creation of cognitive dissonance, this state of perplexity, is not an end in itself but a necessary preparation. It makes the assembly receptive to the radical, seemingly paradoxical explanation of the Buddha’s eternal nature that is essential for understanding the Sūtra’s deepest message. The drama is thus a skillful means (upāya) designed to facilitate a fundamental shift in perspective, paving the way for the revelations of the honmon.

III. Key Figures in the Dialogue: Shakyamuni and Maitreya

The dialogue between Shakyamuni Buddha and Maitreya Bodhisattva forms the core of Chapter 15’s dramatic tension and functions as the hinge upon which the Sūtra pivots towards its essential teaching. Their respective roles are crucial for understanding the chapter’s purpose and message.

A. Shakyamuni Buddha

In this chapter, Shakyamuni embodies several key roles:

• The Authoritative Teacher: As the World-Honored One, he is the source of the Dharma being expounded.¹⁴ His words carry ultimate authority, even when they appear paradoxical.
• The Revealer of Paradox: His central act in this chapter is the assertion that the countless, ancient-seeming Bodhisattvas emerging from the earth are his own disciples, whom he has personally guided since the remote past.⁷ This claim directly clashes with the universally accepted understanding among the assembly that he attained enlightenment only about forty years prior, near Gaya in India.⁷ He is deliberately presenting a teaching that challenges the limits of their current understanding.
• The Architect of Revelation: By making this seemingly impossible claim, Shakyamuni masterfully sets the stage for the subsequent revelation in Chapter 16, “Life Span of the Thus Come One.” The temporal paradox he introduces necessitates the disclosure of his true identity—not merely the historical Buddha of India, but the Buddha who attained enlightenment countless kalpas (eons) ago (gohyaku jintengō).⁵ This act embodies the principle of “opening the near and revealing the distant” (kai gon ken non), moving from the provisional, historical manifestation to the fundamental, eternal reality.²⁷
• The Compassionate Guide: Despite the bewildering nature of his statements, Shakyamuni’s actions display profound compassion. His initial refusal of help from the visiting Bodhisattvas can be interpreted as ensuring that his own disciples, intrinsically connected to the sahā world, undertake the vital mission of propagation and gain the associated merit.¹⁶ Furthermore, his eventual willingness to explain the paradox, prompted by Maitreya’s plea, is explicitly for the sake of future believers who might harbor doubts.⁷ He guides beings by first challenging their assumptions and then providing the deeper understanding.

B. Maitreya Bodhisattva

Maitreya plays an equally vital role as the primary interlocutor representing the assembly:

• Distinguished Disciple: Maitreya is recognized within the Mahayana tradition as a principal Bodhisattva, residing in the Tuṣita heaven and destined to be the next Buddha to appear in this world.⁷ His high status lends weight to the doubts he expresses.
• Voice of the Assembly’s Doubt: He perfectly articulates the collective astonishment, confusion, and logical difficulty experienced by the entire assembly—including highly advanced Bodhisattvas from other worlds—upon witnessing the emergence of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth and hearing Shakyamuni’s claim regarding their origin.⁷ The text explicitly states he knows the thoughts arising in the minds of the others.¹⁴
• The Skillful and Sincere Questioner: Maitreya’s questioning is portrayed not as a sign of weak faith or disrespect, but as an act of sincere and intelligent inquiry.⁷ He does not passively accept a statement that contradicts reason and the assembly’s direct experience. His honesty and courage in voicing the apparent contradiction in front of the vast assembly are implicitly lauded.²⁴ His request for clarification is presented as necessary for the understanding and faith of both present and future disciples.⁷
• Catalyst for Deeper Revelation: It is precisely Maitreya’s well-articulated doubt and persistent questioning that prompts Shakyamuni to proceed with the profound revelations of Chapter 16.⁷ His inquiry acts as the necessary trigger, demonstrating the assembly’s readiness (or need) to receive the deeper teaching about the Buddha’s eternal nature.

The dynamic interplay between Shakyamuni and Maitreya in this chapter reveals a crucial aspect of how profound Dharma is transmitted. The revelation of ultimate truth is presented not as a simple, unilateral declaration by the Buddha, but as an interactive process. It requires the teacher to present teachings, sometimes paradoxical ones that challenge existing frameworks, and it equally requires the disciple’s sincere engagement, critical inquiry, and honest expression of doubt when faced with apparent contradictions. Shakyamuni presents the puzzle; Maitreya, representing the earnest seeker, identifies the inconsistencies based on current understanding and asks for resolution, specifically citing the need for clarity for future generations. It is only in response to this mature and necessary questioning that the Buddha unveils the deeper, resolving truth in the subsequent chapter. This suggests that the disciple’s capacity for thoughtful doubt and sincere inquiry is not an obstacle to understanding but an essential prerequisite for receiving the highest teachings. The truth is unveiled through this respectful yet challenging dialogue.

IV. The Bodhisattvas Emerging from the Earth

The dramatic appearance of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth (jiyu no bosatsu) is the central event of Chapter 15 and carries immense symbolic and doctrinal weight within the Lotus Sūtra and its subsequent interpretations.

A. Identity and Origin

• Original Disciples of the Eternal Buddha: Shakyamuni unequivocally identifies these Bodhisattvas as his own disciples, whom he has been personally teaching and guiding since the inconceivably remote past (kuon).⁷ In the context of the Sūtra’s division, they are the “Bodhisattvas of the essential teaching” (honge no bosatsu), directly connected to the “Original Buddha” whose eternal nature is revealed in Chapter 16.⁹ Their existence serves as evidence for the Buddha’s own ancient attainment.
• Originating from Beneath the Sahā World: Crucially, these Bodhisattvas emerge not from distant Pure Lands or other Buddha-fields, but from the void or space beneath this very sahā world—the world of endurance, suffering, and impermanence.² This specific origin distinguishes them sharply from the visiting Bodhisattvas from “other worlds” whose help Shakyamuni declined.⁷ Their connection is intrinsically with this world.
• Incalculable Numbers: Their multitude is described using hyperbolic terms—limitless, boundless, beyond calculation, equaling the sands of sixty thousand Ganges Rivers, each with similarly vast retinues.⁷ This staggering number emphasizes the immense scale and duration of the Buddha’s compassionate activity throughout beginningless time and the vast potential for Buddhahood within the sahā world itself.

B. Symbolism

The emergence and nature of these Bodhisattvas are rich with symbolic meaning:

• Inherent Potential and Buddha-Nature: Their dramatic welling forth from the earth is widely interpreted as symbolizing the inherent potential for enlightenment, the Buddha-nature (buddhadhātu), that exists within all beings dwelling in this world, even if it lies dormant or concealed by defilements.⁹ As the early Chinese commentator Tao Sheng suggested, this event indicates that the inherent endowment for enlightenment within beings cannot remain hidden and is “bound to break the earth of defilements and emerge to safeguard the Dharma”.⁹ They represent the awakening of this inner potential from the very ground of our existence.²⁰
• Grounding in This World (Sahā): Their origin from beneath this world, rather than from an external paradise, signifies that the path to enlightenment and the responsibility for propagating the Dharma are fundamentally rooted in the reality of this world of suffering.⁹ It affirms, as interpreted by Thich Nhat Hanh, that the people of this world are themselves capable of being the caretakers and propagators of the ultimate teaching.⁹ Their karmic connection is specifically to the beings of the sahā world.³²
• Metaphor for Grassroots Action: The image of countless Bodhisattvas emerging from the ground has been employed as a powerful metaphor for the rise of grassroots Buddhist movements, emphasizing the power and potential of ordinary people awakening to their mission and taking collective action for the Dharma.⁹ They are seen not as distant celestial beings but as “plain, ordinary people, utterly and fully human champions” who engage with the world.¹⁸
• Embodiment of Practice and Compassionate Action: These Bodhisattvas are characterized as “doers” who exemplify the truth through their compassionate conduct and dedicated practice.⁹ Their primary mission, revealed through the chapter, is the active propagation and protection of the Lotus Sūtra in the challenging times to come.¹⁰ The inclusion of “Practices” (cāritra) in the names of their four leaders underscores this emphasis on action.¹⁰ Nichiren Buddhism specifically identifies their core action as the chanting and propagation of Nam-myoho-renge-kyo.¹⁰
• Symbolism of the Four Leaders: The four leaders—Superior Practices, Boundless Practices, Pure Practices, and Firmly Established Practices—are often interpreted as personifying key Mahayana ideals. They may represent the four universal Bodhisattva vows, or, particularly in relation to the essential teaching, the four virtues characterizing the eternal life of the Buddha revealed in Chapter 16: True Self (ātman), Eternity (nitya), Purity (śubha), and Joy (sukha).⁹

C. Significance

The appearance of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth holds profound significance within the framework of the Lotus Sūtra:

• Entrusted Propagators for the Future Age: They are explicitly designated by Shakyamuni as the ones entrusted with the difficult task of propagating the essential teaching of the Lotus Sūtra (identified as the Mystic Law, Nam-myoho-renge-kyo, in Nichiren tradition) during the perilous future era known as the Latter Day of the Law (mappō).⁷ They are the appointed “guiding teachers of the Latter Day”.¹⁰
• Validation of the Eternal Buddha: Their existence and ancient connection to Shakyamuni serve as living proof of the Buddha’s own attainment of enlightenment in the remote past, the central revelation of Chapter 16. Only a Buddha whose existence transcends conventional time could have cultivated such an immense assembly of advanced disciples over countless eons.⁹
• Marking the Shift from Theory to Practice: Their emergence signifies a crucial transition within the Sūtra’s message, moving beyond the theoretical expositions of the first fourteen chapters towards an emphasis on practical application, compassionate action, and engagement within the complexities of this world.⁹ As Nikkyo Niwano stated, they are the “doers” who apply the knowledge of the truth in practice.⁹

A deeper examination reveals how the origin of these Bodhisattvas constitutes a radical reframing of the source and potential for enlightenment. By having them emerge from beneath the sahā world—the very ground of suffering—rather than descending from celestial Pure Lands or arriving from other idealized realms ⁷, the Sūtra challenges hierarchical models where salvation or enlightenment is bestowed from an external, transcendent source. Instead, it locates the highest potential within the immanent reality of worldly existence. This suggests that Buddhahood is not merely a distant goal to be reached by escaping this world, but a potential inherent within it, capable of arising organically from the soil of suffering and confusion. This powerfully grounds the Mahayana ideal of universal enlightenment within the lived reality of the sahā world.

Furthermore, the Bodhisattvas of the Earth can be understood as embodying the Mahayana principle of the non-duality of samsara and nirvana. They are ancient disciples intrinsically linked to the eternal, ultimate reality of the Buddha revealed in Chapter 16.⁹ Yet, they dwell within and emerge from the sahā world, the realm of conditioned existence, impermanence, and suffering.⁹ Their specific mission is to actively engage in practice and propagation within this challenging world, particularly during the difficult Latter Day of the Law.⁷ This positioning—simultaneously rooted in the ultimate (the eternal Buddha) while acting within the phenomenal (sahā world)—effectively bridges the apparent dichotomy between the sacred and the profane, the absolute and the relative. They demonstrate that enlightenment is not achieved by abandoning the world, but through transformative engagement within it, reflecting profound Mahayana concepts like “samsara is nirvana” ³⁴ and “earthly desires are enlightenment”.³⁵

V. The Source of Perplexity: The Buddha’s Revealed Teaching

The central teaching revealed by Shakyamuni Buddha in Chapter 15—the claim that the newly emerged, innumerable, and ancient-seeming Bodhisattvas of the Earth are his own disciples whom he has taught since the remote past—is the direct source of the profound perplexity experienced by Maitreya and the entire assembly. This perplexity arises from a fundamental clash between the Buddha’s statement and the established understanding of his life and timeline.

A. The Apparent Contradiction

The core of the issue lies in a seemingly irreconcilable temporal paradox. The assembly, including advanced Bodhisattvas, understands Shakyamuni as the historical figure who attained enlightenment under the Bodhi tree near Gaya only some forty years prior to the current gathering.⁷ This timeframe is firmly established in their minds. However, the Buddha now claims parentage, in a spiritual sense, over a vast host of Bodhisattvas who are clearly depicted as having practiced for “immeasurable kalpas” and possess qualities indicative of immense spiritual maturity attained over eons.⁷ How could a teacher with only forty years of experience have possibly nurtured disciples of such profound antiquity and accomplishment? This is the logical knot that Maitreya articulates.

B. Challenging Conventional Time

This teaching fundamentally challenges the linear, historical conception of time held by the audience. It implies that the Buddha’s existence and teaching activities operate on a scale that vastly transcends ordinary human lifespans and historical chronology.⁷ The claim necessitates a reality where the Buddha’s influence stretches back into an unfathomable past, far beyond his recent appearance in India.

C. Implication of a Deeper Identity

Implicit within this perplexing claim is the foreshadowing of a radically different understanding of Shakyamuni’s identity. If he has been teaching these ancient Bodhisattvas since long ago, then he cannot simply be the historical prince Siddhartha who achieved enlightenment in his lifetime. He must possess a deeper, more fundamental identity—that of the “Original Buddha” or “Eternal Buddha” whose enlightenment occurred in the infinitely remote past (kuon jitsujō). Chapter 15 thus functions as a dramatic setup, creating the intellectual need for the explicit revelation of this eternal nature, which follows in Chapter 16, “Life Span of the Thus Come One”.⁵

D. The Scale of the Disciples

The sheer scale of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth—their “immeasurable thousands, ten thousands, millions” ¹⁴ and their advanced qualities (“firm in their intent,” “power of great perseverance,” “unfathomable in wisdom” acquired through practice over “immeasurable kalpas” ¹⁴)—amplifies the incredulity. Training even one such Bodhisattva would seem a monumental task; training countless hosts appears utterly impossible within the conventional forty-year timeframe. The magnitude of the effect (the BoE) seems vastly disproportionate to the perceived cause (Shakyamuni’s recent enlightenment).

The strategic function of this perplexing teaching can be understood through the concept of “upsetting attachments and arousing doubts” (hotsu shakku ken pon), a principle particularly highlighted in interpretations of this chapter.²² The assembly is attached to a specific, limited, historical view of the Buddha. By presenting a teaching that directly contradicts this ingrained belief, Shakyamuni intentionally “upsets” this attachment. This generates cognitive dissonance—doubt and perplexity—voiced so clearly by Maitreya. This state of doubt, however, is not negative; it signifies the breakdown of a limited conceptual framework. It creates an essential opening, a state of readiness and intellectual curiosity, making the assembly receptive to a more profound, non-linear, and ultimately liberating understanding of Buddhahood, time, and reality that transcends their previous assumptions. The perplexing statement in Chapter 15 is thus a skillful pedagogical maneuver, destabilizing a provisional understanding to prepare the ground for the revelation of the fundamental truth in Chapter 16.

VI. Unbelievable Yet True: Maitreya’s Analogy

Faced with the Buddha’s astonishing claim, Maitreya Bodhisattva employs a striking analogy to articulate the depth of the assembly’s incredulity and the perceived violation of natural order and common sense. This analogy serves not only to express doubt but also to concretize the abstract temporal paradox presented.

A. The Analogy Stated

Maitreya paints a vivid picture of a scenario universally recognized as impossible within ordinary human experience:

Suppose, for example, that a young man of twenty-five, with ruddy complexion and hair still black, should point to someone who was a hundred years old and say, ‘This is my son!’ or that the hundred year old man should point to the youth and say, ‘This is my father who sired and raised me!’ This would be hard to believe, and so too is what the Buddha says. ¹⁴

He reiterates this in verse form, emphasizing the visual contrast and the violation of expected…source Highlighting the Temporal Paradox: Its primary function is to starkly illustrate the seemingly impossible contradiction in timeframes. The youthful appearance and age (twenty-five) maps onto Shakyamuni’s relatively recent enlightenment and forty-year ministry, while the advanced age (one hundred years) and venerable appearance (“gray hair and wrinkled face”) map onto the perceived antiquity and profound attainment of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth, who have practiced for “measurable kalpas”.¹⁴ It makes the temporal discrepancy immediately apparent.

• Expressing Collective Incredulity: The analogy powerfully conveys the depth of disbelief felt by Maitreya and the entire assembly. By stating “no one in the world could believe this,” Maitreya emphasizes that the Buddha’s claim falls far outside the bounds of accepted reality and rational understanding.¹⁴ It validates the assembly’s confusion as a natural response based on their experience.
• Underscoring the Limits of Conventional View: Implicitly, the analogy highlights the inadequacy of ordinary, linear perception and conventional logic when attempting to grasp the boundless nature of Buddhahood and the non-linear conception of time being introduced in the essential teaching. What seems impossible from a limited viewpoint may be true from a higher perspective.
• Distinction from Other Lotus Sūtra Parables: It is important to differentiate this analogy from other well-known parables in the Lotus Sūtra. Parables like the Burning House (illustrating skillful means to save beings from samsara) ⁸ or the Prodigal Son/Poor Son (illustrating the gradual path to recognizing one’s inherent Buddha-nature) ⁸ serve different pedagogical purposes. Maitreya’s analogy of the young father and old sons is unique in its specific focus on clarifying the temporal paradox presented by the relationship between Shakyamuni and the Bodhisattvas of the Earth as revealed uniquely in Chapter 15.

While expressing profound disbelief, Maitreya’s analogy paradoxically functions as a crucial bridge for understanding. The Buddha’s claim involves vast, abstract concepts—countless Bodhisattvas, immeasurable eons, the nature of enlightenment across time—which are difficult for the mind to grasp directly.⁷ Maitreya translates this abstract temporal paradox into a simple, concrete, albeit unbelievable, image drawn from familiar human relationships and lifespans.¹⁴ Although the scenario itself is impossible in the ordinary world, its structure perfectly mirrors the structure of the logical problem posed by the Buddha’s words. This allows the cognitive faculties of the assembly to engage with the form of the paradox, even if the content remains baffling. By making the inconceivable thinkable, even if still unbelievable according to conventional logic, the analogy prepares the minds of the listeners to receive the explanation—the revelation of the Buddha’s eternal lifespan—that will ultimately resolve the apparent contradiction. It makes the problem tangible, paving the way for its resolution.

VII. The Gateway to Understanding: Doubt and Inquiry in Buddhist Practice

Chapter 15 of the Lotus Sūtra offers a profound perspective on the role of doubt and questioning within the Buddhist path to understanding. Far from portraying doubt as inherently negative, the interaction between Maitreya and Shakyamuni elevates sincere inquiry to a necessary component of engaging with deep Dharma truths.

A. Maitreya’s Doubt as Exemplary Inquiry

Maitreya Bodhisattva’s expression of doubt, stemming from genuine perplexity when faced with a teaching that contradicts reason and experience, is presented as a model of intelligent and courageous engagement.²² He does not resort to blind acceptance of the inconceivable, nor does he dismiss the Buddha’s words [User Query]. Instead, he respectfully but clearly articulates the logical inconsistency he perceives. His honesty in admitting non-comprehension, even before the vast assembly, is framed positively, transforming a potential “weakness” into the strength of seeking clarity.²⁴ His actions exemplify a mature approach to spiritual learning that values understanding.

B. Doubt as a Catalyst for Deeper Truth

The narrative structure makes it clear that Maitreya’s questioning is the essential catalyst prompting Shakyamuni to reveal the profound doctrine of his eternal lifespan in Chapter 16.⁷ The Buddha’s initial statement creates the paradox, but it is the disciple’s active questioning that opens the door for the deeper explanation. This demonstrates a principle where sincere doubt, far from being an obstacle, can be the very key that unlocks more profound levels of teaching. The teacher responds to the readiness and the need demonstrated by the student’s inquiry.

C. Distinguishing Constructive Doubt from Negative Doubt

Mahayana Buddhist thought, as reflected in this context and related discussions, implicitly distinguishes between different kinds of doubt. There is the paralyzing doubt born of cynicism or fundamental delusion (avidyā), which is seen as a root of suffering (“fundamental darkness”).⁴⁰ However, there is also investigative doubt (vicikitsā), the kind exemplified by Maitreya, which motivates a search for understanding and clarity. Buddhism, particularly in its Mahayana expressions, encourages investigation and reason, not blind faith.⁴⁰ Faith is often described as a process involving a “spirit of reverent searching”.⁴⁰ Uninvestigated doubts can fester and hinder progress, but doubts that are honestly faced and pursued through inquiry lead to deeper conviction and wisdom.⁴⁰ The aim is not to remain in doubt, but to resolve it through the process of investigation, leading to a more robust and informed faith.

D. Doubt and the Concern for Future Generations

Maitreya explicitly frames his request for clarification as being made “especially for the sake of people in the future who may have doubts about this point”.⁷ This highlights a compassionate concern for the continuity and accessibility of the Dharma. It acknowledges that future generations will likely encounter the same intellectual and experiential challenges when grappling with profound teachings like the Buddha’s eternal nature. Addressing these potential doubts proactively is presented as crucial for ensuring the efficacy and credibility of the teaching across time.

E. The Principle of “Upsetting Attachments and Arousing Doubts”

The process observed in Chapter 15 is directly linked to the pedagogical principle of “upsetting attachments and arousing doubts”.²² By challenging the assembly’s fixed belief (attachment) regarding his historical enlightenment, the Buddha generates doubt. This doubt, in turn, creates the necessary mental space and motivation for the assembly to receive and integrate a far more expansive understanding of reality.²² This process is seen as fundamental to spiritual growth, even though challenging cherished beliefs can often lead to encountering resistance or obstacles.²²

Viewed through this lens, Maitreya’s doubt is more than just intellectual curiosity; it signifies a profound level of engagement with the Buddha’s teaching. It demonstrates that he is taking the Dharma seriously enough to grapple with its implications, inconsistencies, and challenges, rather than resorting to superficial acceptance or easy dismissal. His doubt arises precisely because he is attempting to integrate the Buddha’s words with his existing understanding and finds a conflict. This active wrestling with the teaching, born from a desire for genuine comprehension, is presented as a more authentic and fruitful form of engagement than passive belief. His doubt is, in essence, an expression of his earnest commitment to understanding the truth being revealed.

VIII. Diverse Perspectives: Interpretations Across Buddhist Traditions

Chapter 15 of the Lotus Sūtra, with its dramatic emergence of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth and the ensuing paradox, has generated rich and diverse interpretations across various Mahayana Buddhist schools. These interpretations often reflect the specific doctrinal emphases and practical concerns of each tradition.

A. Tendai (Tiantai) School (Zhiyi)

The Tiantai school, founded by Zhiyi (538–597) in China and transmitted to Japan as Tendai, developed a highly influential hermeneutical framework for understanding the Lotus Sūtra.

• Theoretical vs. Essential Teaching Division: Central to Zhiyi’s interpretation is the division of the Sūtra into the theoretical teaching (shakumon, Ch 1-14) and the essential teaching (honmon, Ch 15-28).¹¹ Chapter 15 marks the crucial transition into the honmon, the section revealing the Buddha’s original, fundamental nature.⁷
• Function of Chapter 15: Zhiyi viewed the first part of Chapter 15 as a ‘preparation’ (jo) for the essential teaching, while the second part, along with Chapter 16 (“Life Span”) and the first half of Chapter 17, constitutes the ‘revelation’ (shō) section of the honmon.¹² The dramatic emergence of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth serves to prepare the assembly for, and necessitate, the core revelation of the honmon: the Buddha’s attainment of enlightenment in the inconceivably remote past (kuon jitsujō) and his immeasurable lifespan, as explicitly detailed in Chapter 16.¹³ This revelation of the eternal Buddha is considered the ultimate message of the Sūtra in the Tendai view.¹³
• Focus on Principles: Tendai analysis often interprets the events and figures of the Sūtra through the lens of profound philosophical principles, such as the Three Truths (emptiness, provisional existence, and the middle way) and the doctrine of “three thousand realms in a single moment of life” (ichinen sanzen). The Lotus Sūtra is seen as the perfect expression of these principles, unifying all Buddhist teachings within the One Vehicle.¹² The Bodhisattvas of the Earth would be understood within this framework as manifestations connected to the ultimate reality and the timeless, compassionate activity of the eternal Buddha.

B. Nichiren Buddhism

Nichiren Daishonin (1222–1282) and the schools stemming from his teachings place extraordinary emphasis on Chapter 15 and the Bodhisattvas of the Earth.

• Centrality of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth: These Bodhisattvas are considered figures of paramount importance.⁹ They are identified as the true disciples of the eternal Buddha revealed in Chapter 16, trained by him since the remote past.⁹
• Mission in the Latter Day of the Law (Mappō): The primary significance of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth lies in their specific mission: they are entrusted by Shakyamuni with propagating the essence of the Lotus Sūtra—identified by Nichiren as Nam-myoho-renge-kyo (the daimoku)—in the present degenerate age, the Latter Day of the Law.⁹ Their fundamental practice and action (gyō) is the chanting and spreading of the daimoku.⁹
• Nichiren as Bodhisattva Superior Practices: Nichiren identified himself as the votary of the Lotus Sūtra predicted to appear in the Latter Day and, in several writings, as the reincarnation or functional equivalent of Bodhisattva Superior Practices (Jōgyō), the leader of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth, fulfilling the Sūtra’s prophecy for this age.⁹
• Practitioners as Bodhisattvas of the Earth: Crucially, Nichiren taught that his followers who embrace and propagate Nam-myoho-renge-kyo with the same commitment in the Latter Day are also fulfilling the role and mission of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth.⁹ Realizing this identity and mission (“awareness as Bodhisattvas of the Earth”) is considered fundamental to their practice and spirit.¹⁰ Various Nichiren schools (e.g., Soka Gakkai, Nichiren Shū, Nichiren Shoshu) hold distinct nuances in their understanding of how contemporary practitioners embody this role.⁹
• Facing Obstacles as Proof: Nichiren Buddhism emphasizes the Lotus Sūtra’s predictions that its votaries in the Latter Day will inevitably face persecution and obstacles (“three powerful enemies”). Encountering such difficulties while propagating the Law is interpreted not as failure, but as proof of correct practice in accordance with the Sūtra’s teachings.¹¹

C. Other Perspectives

• Zen (Dōgen): The founder of the Sōtō Zen school in Japan, Dōgen Kigen (1200–1253), also engaged with the Lotus Sūtra. He reportedly found the emergence of the Bodhisattvas in Chapter 15 and the revelation of the Buddha’s long lifespan in Chapter 16 significant.⁹ These elements could be interpreted as supporting the Zen emphasis on the possibility of immediate awakening (kenshō) grounded in one’s fundamental nature, viewing Buddhahood not solely as a distant goal achieved over lifetimes but as an ever-present potential actualized through practice.⁹
• Thich Nhat Hanh: The modern Vietnamese Zen master offered interpretations aligning with general Mahayana humanism. He saw the emergence of the Bodhisattvas from the earth as affirming the capacity of ordinary people within this world to take responsibility for the Dharma, and as highlighting the infinite universality of life inherent in all beings.⁹
• General Mahayana Understanding: Beyond specific schools, the Bodhisattvas of the Earth generally symbolize the vast, inherent potential for enlightenment within the world (Buddha-nature) ⁹, the importance of practice being grounded in the reality of this world rather than seeking escape ⁹, and the sheer scale and timelessness of the Buddha’s compassionate efforts to guide beings.

Comparative Interpretations of Lotus Sūtra Chapter 15

Feature / School	Tendai (Zhiyi)	Nichiren Buddhism	Zen (Dōgen) / Thich Nhat Hanh (General)
Ch 15 Significance	Marks start of Essential Teaching (honmon); Preparation/Revelation for Ch 16 12	Start of Essential Teaching; Revelation of BoE mission; Empowerment for Mappō practice 9	Illustrates immediate potential; Universality; Groundedness 9
Bodhisattvas of Earth	Manifestations linked to eternal Buddha & ultimate principles (Implicit)	True disciples; Propagators of Nam-myoho-renge-kyo in Latter Day; Practitioners embody BoE role 9	Symbolize inherent potential; Rootedness in sahā; Embodiment of practice/action 9
Key Doctrine Focus	Buddha’s Eternal Lifespan (Ch 16); One Vehicle; Three Truths 12	Nam-myoho-renge-kyo; Latter Day Propagation; Attaining Buddhahood in this lifetime 10	Immediate Awakening; Universality of Life; Inherent Buddha-Nature 9
Buddha Conception	Eternal Buddha (Original Attainment) as primary; Historical Buddha as trace 13	Eternal Buddha (Original Attainment) is fundamental; Nichiren as Buddha of Latter Day 5	Eternal aspect emphasizes timeless potential & presence 9

The diversity evident in these interpretations underscores how a school’s foundational tenets, historical context, and practical orientation act as a powerful interpretive lens. This lens focuses attention on and amplifies particular elements within the rich tapestry of Chapter 15. For Tendai, with its emphasis on comprehensive doctrinal classification and meditative insight, Chapter 15 serves primarily as the necessary prelude to the ultimate philosophical revelation of the eternal Buddha in Chapter 16.¹² For Nichiren, whose central concern was establishing the correct practice for salvation in the perceived degenerate age of mappō, Chapter 15 becomes paramount, identifying the agents (the BoE, embodied by Nichiren and his followers) and the method (chanting Nam-myoho-renge-kyo) for achieving enlightenment here and now.⁹ Other Mahayana perspectives draw on the chapter’s potent imagery to support broader themes like inherent potential and universal compassion.⁹ This demonstrates the dynamic interplay between a canonical text and its interpretive communities, where the Sūtra’s profound depth allows for multiple, contextually relevant, yet distinct readings, each unlocking different facets of its meaning.

IX. Synthesizing the Meaning: Philosophical Implications

Chapter 15 of the Lotus Sūtra, serving as the dramatic gateway to the essential teaching (honmon), carries profound philosophical implications that reverberate throughout Mahayana Buddhist thought. Its narrative and revelations challenge fundamental assumptions about the nature of Buddhahood, time, faith, and the path to enlightenment itself.

A. Nature of Buddhahood: Transcending History

The chapter initiates a radical shift in the conception of Buddhahood. The perplexity generated by Shakyamuni’s claim regarding the Bodhisattvas of the Earth necessitates moving beyond the image of the Buddha solely as the historical figure who attained enlightenment under the Bodhi tree in India. It points towards the understanding, fully elaborated in Chapter 16, of the Buddha as an eternal, timeless reality—a being whose enlightenment occurred in the inconceivably distant past (kuon jitsujō) and whose compassionate activity is ongoing and ever-present.¹ This eternal Buddha is not merely a historical founder but the embodiment of enlightenment itself, manifesting in various forms throughout time and space to guide beings. Some interpretations take this further, identifying this eternal Buddha ultimately with the fundamental reality of life inherent in all beings: “We are all ‘eternal Buddhas’”.⁵

B. Nature of Time: Beyond Linearity

The temporal paradox at the heart of the chapter—the “young father” (recently enlightened Buddha) and the “old sons” (ancient Bodhisattvas)—forces a re-evaluation of the conventional, linear understanding of time. The revelation of the Buddha’s “immeasurable, boundless” (apramāṇa) lifespan, spanning countless kalpas, suggests a view of time that is cyclical, multi-dimensional, or perhaps ultimately illusory from the enlightened perspective.¹ Past, present, and future are not necessarily sequential fixed points but may be simultaneously present or interconnected within the Buddha’s wisdom. The eternal Buddha’s constant presence “throughout the three existences” (past, present, future) points to this transcendence of linear duration.⁵

C. Faith and Inquiry: An Integrated Path

Chapter 15 champions a sophisticated model of spiritual development where faith and inquiry are not opposed but deeply integrated. Maitreya’s doubt, born of sincere perplexity when confronted with a teaching that defies conventional logic, is presented as a valid and necessary step towards deeper understanding.¹⁶ His courageous questioning acts as the catalyst for the Buddha to reveal a more profound truth. This suggests that authentic faith in Mahayana Buddhism is not blind acceptance but a dynamic process that involves actively grappling with difficult questions, using reason and investigation to penetrate deeper layers of meaning, ultimately leading to a more robust and informed conviction.⁴⁰

D. Skillful Means (Upāya)

The entire dramatic sequence of Chapter 15—Shakyamuni’s refusal of the visiting Bodhisattvas, the earth-shattering emergence of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth, his perplexing claim about their origin, Maitreya’s ensuing doubt and analogy, all leading to the revelations of Chapter 16—can be viewed as a masterful display of skillful means (upāya).¹ The Buddha employs apparent contradictions and leverages the disciples’ own process of inquiry to guide them toward a truth that might be too radical or overwhelming if presented directly. By first destabilizing their existing framework, he creates the conditions for them to receive and appreciate the profound teaching of his eternal nature.²⁷ The famous parable of the skillful physician in Chapter 16, who feigns death to induce his poisoned sons to take medicine, further illustrates this principle of using expedient methods out of compassion to lead beings to truth and well-being.²⁷

E. Immanence of Enlightenment

The striking image of the Bodhisattvas emerging from beneath the sahā world powerfully underscores the Mahayana theme of the immanence of enlightenment.⁹ Rather than portraying liberation as solely dependent on external Buddhas or achievable only in distant Pure Lands, this event suggests that the highest potential for Buddhahood, and the agents capable of realizing it, arise from within the very fabric of this world of suffering. It affirms that enlightenment is not merely a transcendent state separate from samsara, but a potential inherent within it, waiting to be unearthed. This resonates with teachings on the non-duality of realms and the possibility of transforming this world into a Buddha land (“This, my land, remains safe and tranquil”).⁵

F. Centrality of Practice and Action

By entrusting the crucial mission of propagating the Dharma in the Latter Day specifically to the Bodhisattvas of the Earth, the chapter highlights the indispensable role of practice, action, and compassionate engagement in the world.⁹ These Bodhisattvas are not passive recipients of wisdom but active agents (“doers”) whose task is to embody and share the teaching through diligent effort within society. This emphasizes that realizing and manifesting enlightenment involves not just understanding, but dedicated practice and tireless work for the benefit of others.

Examining the interplay between the absolute and the relative provides further depth. Chapter 15 masterfully orchestrates a confrontation between the assembly’s relative, historical understanding ⁷ and the sudden intrusion of the absolute—represented by the boundless number, ancient nature, and ultimate origin (from the eternal Buddha) of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth.⁷ Maitreya’s doubt arises precisely from the impossibility of containing this absolute phenomenon within the existing relative framework.⁷ The resolution, offered in Chapter 16, involves fundamentally shifting the frame of reference itself by revealing the absolute, eternal nature of the Buddha.²⁷ This narrative arc suggests that accessing or understanding the absolute dimension of reality often requires a breakdown of our attachment to limited, relative viewpoints, a breakdown precipitated by encountering phenomena or teachings that those viewpoints cannot adequately explain.

Furthermore, the revelation that the Bodhisattvas of the Earth are ancient disciples, taught by Shakyamuni since the remote past, radically redefines the conventional understanding of the teacher-disciple relationship. It transcends the bounds of a single lifetime, suggesting an eternal bond and an ongoing, timeless process of teaching and learning intrinsically linked to the Buddha’s boundless compassionate vow.⁷ The Buddha’s teaching activity is thus revealed not as a finite historical event but as an eternal function ⁵, and the disciples (represented by the BoE) are participants in this timeless drama of enlightenment, connected across countless kalpas to their original teacher. This elevates the teacher-disciple connection from a mere historical or personal affiliation to a manifestation of the enduring workings of Buddhahood and universal compassion.

X. Conclusion

Chapter 15, “Emerging from the Earth,” stands as a monumental gateway within the Lotus Sūtra, dramatically ushering in the essential teaching (honmon) and fundamentally altering the landscape of the Sūtra’s message. Its narrative climax—the astonishing emergence of the countless Bodhisattvas of the Earth—and the ensuing dialogue of perplexity between Maitreya and Shakyamuni serve not merely as spectacle, but as profound pedagogical devices. This chapter effectively destabilizes conventional understandings of time, Buddhahood, and the very ground of enlightenment, preparing the audience for the radical revelations concerning the Buddha’s eternal nature presented in the subsequent chapter.

The analysis undertaken in this report has illuminated several key insights arising from Chapter 15. It marks the critical juncture where the Sūtra begins to unveil the concept of the eternal Buddha, moving beyond the historical Shakyamuni to reveal a timeless embodiment of enlightenment deeply engaged with the world across infinite eons. The Bodhisattvas of the Earth, emerging from beneath this world of suffering, serve as powerful symbols of the inherent potential for Buddhahood residing within all beings and the immanence of enlightenment within samsara itself. Their designation as the primary propagators for the future age underscores the paramount importance of practice and compassionate action grounded in this world. Furthermore, the chapter provides a compelling model for the integration of faith and inquiry, portraying sincere doubt not as an obstacle but as a vital catalyst for achieving deeper understanding and a more robust connection to the Dharma. Maitreya’s analogy of the young father and old sons vividly captures the limits of conventional reason when faced with the boundless truths of the essential teaching, while simultaneously bridging the gap between the known and the unknown.

The philosophical implications stemming from this chapter are far-reaching. They include a radical reconceptualization of Buddhahood as eternal and ever-present, a view of time that transcends linear constraints, an affirmation of skillful means (upāya) as a core element of compassionate teaching, and a redefinition of the teacher-disciple relationship as an enduring bond rooted in the Buddha’s timeless vow. The diverse interpretations offered by schools like Tendai and Nichiren Buddhism further attest to the chapter’s enduring power and richness, demonstrating how its themes can be refracted through different doctrinal lenses to address specific soteriological concerns, particularly the path to enlightenment in challenging times.

In essence, Chapter 15 of the Lotus Sūtra serves as a profound call to awaken to a deeper reality. It challenges believers to look beyond surface appearances and historical limitations, to recognize the eternal dimension of Buddhahood reflected in their own inherent potential, and to embrace the responsibility—symbolized by the mission of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth—of actualizing this potential through sincere inquiry, unwavering faith, and dedicated practice for the transformation of oneself and the world. Its legacy continues to inspire Mahayana practitioners to find the extraordinary within the ordinary, the eternal within the ephemeral, and the path to liberation within the very ground of their present existence.

Works cited

1. Lotus Sutra – Wikipedia, accessed April 9, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotus_Sutra
2. Chapter XV – Bodhisattvas Emerging from the Earth, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.wisdomlib.org/buddhism/book/the-lotus-sutra/d/doc62791.html
3. Lotus Sutra, accessed April 9, 2025, http://jamesshields.blogs.bucknell.edu/files/2012/12/Lotus-Sutra.pdf
4. 1 A Modern Interpretation of The Threefold Lotus Sutra Translated by Nikkyo Niwano – Rissho Kosei-Kai Buddhist Center of San Antonio, accessed April 9, 2025, https://rksabuddhistcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/BuddhismforToday.pdf
5. Buddhism: The Wisdom of the Lotus Sutra | Daisaku Ikeda Official …, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.daisakuikeda.org/main/philos/essays-on-buddhism/buddh-lotus.html
6. Nichiren’s Interpretation of the Universality of the Lotus Sutra, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.kokoro-iebs.org/papers/NO/008/pdf/008_Sekido.pdf
7. “Emerging from the Earth” chapter | Dictionary of Buddhism …, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.nichirenlibrary.org/en/dic/Content/E/61
8. Lotus Sutra – The Gold Scales, accessed April 9, 2025, http://oaks.nvg.org/lotus-sutra.html
9. Bodhisattvas of the Earth – Wikipedia, accessed April 9, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bodhisattvas_of_the_Earth
10. Key Passages From The Record of the Orally Transmitted Teachings (Part 10), accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.worldtribune.org/2024/key-passages-from-the-record-of-the-orally-transmitted-teachings-part-10/
11. The Lotus sutra – Dharma Wheel, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.dharmawheel.net/viewtopic.php?t=19772
12. TENDAI AND THE LOTUS SUTRA Profound Meaning of the Lotus Sutra, accessed April 9, 2025, https://tendaiuk.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/tendai-and-the-lotus-sutra.pdf
13. Lotus Sūtra | Religious Significance | 3 | Buddhism & Healing – Red Zambala, accessed April 9, 2025, https://buddhism.redzambala.com/lotus-sutra/lotus-sutra-religious-significance.html
14. The Lotus Sutra[15] – Emerging from the Earth – nichiren.info, accessed April 9, 2025, https://nichiren.info/buddhism/lotussutra/text/chap15.html
15. http://www.nichirenlibrary.org, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.nichirenlibrary.org/en/dic/Content/E/61#:~:text=This%20chapter%20opens%20with%20innumerable,will%20carry%20out%20this%20task.
16. The Wonderful Dharma Lotus Flower Sutra with Commentary 15 – City of Ten Thousand Buddhas, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.cttbusa.org/dfs15/dfs15.asp.html
17. Lotus Sutra – Chapter 15, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.buddhistdoor.com/OldWeb/resources/sutras/lotus/sources/lotus15.htm
18. Part 3: Kosen-rufu and World Peace Chapter 22: The Mission and Vow of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth [22.1] | Soka Gakkai (global), accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.sokaglobal.org/resources/study-materials/buddhist-study/the-wisdom-for-creating-happiness-and-peace/chapter-22-1.html
19. The True Aspect of All Phenomena | WND I – Nichiren Buddhism Library, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.nichirenlibrary.org/en/wnd-1/Content/40
20. The Cluster of Blessings Brought by the Bodhisattvas of the Earth – World Tribune, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.worldtribune.org/2024/the-cluster-of-blessings-brought-by-thebodhisattvas-of-the-earth/
21. On Curing Karmic Disease | WND I – Nichiren Buddhism Library, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.nichirenlibrary.org/en/wnd-1/Content/76
22. Highlights of the September 2024 Study Material – World Tribune, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.worldtribune.org/2024/highlights-of-the-september-2024-study-material/
23. Introduction | LSOC – Nichiren Buddhism Library, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.nichirenlibrary.org/en/lsoc/Content/1
24. Lotus Sutra Chapter 15 – Springing Up Out Of The Earth (Buddhist Cosmology) – YouTube, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hrlkEerd5Js
25. The Lotus Sutra, Chapter 15 – Emerging from the Earth | 《妙法莲华经》 – YouTube, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WMhHrxcwon8
26. Dogen’s Appropriation of Lotus Sutra Ground and Space – Ancient Dragon Zen Gate, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.ancientdragon.org/dogens-appropriation-of-lotus-sutra-ground-and-space/
27. “Life Span of the Thus Come One” chapter | Dictionary of Buddhism, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.nichirenlibrary.org/en/dic/Content/L/34
28. The Question of Maitreya (1) / 84000 Reading Room, accessed April 9, 2025, https://84000.co/translation/toh85
29. Sutra of Maitreya Buddha / Sutra of Mañjuśrī’s Questions – dBET PDF Version © 2017, accessed April 9, 2025, https://bdkamerica.org/download/1955
30. The Selection of the Time | WND I – Nichiren Buddhism Library, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.nichirenlibrary.org/en/wnd-1/Content/66
31. Strengthening Our Grassroots Network of Bodhisattvas of the Earth for the Peace and Security of Humanity – World Tribune, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.worldtribune.org/2023/strengthening-our-grassroots-network-of-bodhisattvas-of-the-earth/
32. Bodhisattvas of the Earth – Dharma Wheel, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.dharmawheel.net/viewtopic.php?t=29242
33. Part 2: Human Revolution Chapter 15: “Faith for Overcoming Obstacles” [15.9], accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.sokaglobal.org/resources/study-materials/buddhist-study/the-wisdom-for-creating-happiness-and-peace/chapter-15-9.html
34. an analysis of Zhiyi’s interpretation of the concept of “dhyana” in his Shi chanboluomi cidi famen – Dharma Wheel, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.dharmawheel.net/viewtopic.php?t=39565
35. The Essential Passage in Each of the Twenty-eight Chapters of the Lotus Sutra | OTT, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.nichirenlibrary.org/en/ott/Separate-Transmission/1
36. Lotus Sūtra | Summary | 2 | Buddhism & Healing – Red Zambala, accessed April 9, 2025, https://buddhism.redzambala.com/lotus-sutra/lotus-sutra-summary-2.html
37. Question about Burning House Parable in Lotus Sutra – Dharma Wheel, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.dharmawheel.net/viewtopic.php?t=25804
38. Parables of the Lotus Sutra: The Wealthy Man and His Poor Son, accessed April 9, 2025, https://tricycle.org/article/lotus-sutra-prodigal-son/
39. 152 – Lotus Sutra 3: This Means YOU – The Lost Son Parable – The Zen Studies Podcast, accessed April 9, 2025, https://zenstudiespodcast.com/lost-son-parable-lotus-sutra/
40. Superstition, doubt, reason and investigation – Buddhastate, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.buddhastate.com/2012/05/superstition-doubt-reason-and-investigation/
41. Tiantai Hermeneutics: Zhiyi’s Interpretation of the Lotus Sutra Presented in the Miaofa lianhua jing xuanyi, accessed April 9, 2025, https://otani.repo.nii.ac.jp/record/10566/files/11_Robert%20F.%20Rhodes.pdf
42. A Votary of the Lotus Sutra Will Meet Ordeals: The Role of Suffering in Nichiren’s Thought (1) – Princeton University, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.princeton.edu/~jstone/Articles%20on%20the%20Lotus%20Sutra%20Tendai%20and%20Nichiren%20Buddhism/A%20Votary%20of%20the%20Lotus%20Sutra%20Will%20Meet%20Ordeals%20–The%20Role%20of%20Suffering%20in%20Nichiren’s%20Thought%20(2014).pdf
43. The Lotus Sutra as a Source for Dogen’s Discourse Style – thezensite, accessed April 9, 2025, http://www.thezensite.com/ZenEssays/DogenStudies/The_Lotus_Sutra_as_a_Source.html
44. Lotus Sutra – Chapter 16 – Buddhistdoor.net, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.buddhistdoor.com/OldWeb/resources/sutras/lotus/sources/lotus16.htm
45. Chapter 16, The Lotus Sutra: Life Span of a Buddha – Thus Have I Seen (and Heard), accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.zhaxizhuoma.org/chapter-16-the-lotus-sutra-life-span-of-a-buddha/
46. Lotus Sutra Chapter 16 – The Eternal Life of the Buddha – YouTube, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJPvNh6Qdaw
47. Lectures on the Hoben and Juryo Chapters of the Lotus Sutra by SGI President Daisaku Ikeda – nichiren.info, accessed April 9, 2025, http://nichiren.info/buddhism/library/SokaGakkai/Study/LectLS/Lectur16.htm
48. 字幕 Lotus Sutra Chapter 16: PRACTICAL Explanation – YouTube, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=daw1mtG9LL8
49. Chapter 15 | 500 Yojanas, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.500yojanas.org/lotus-sutra/kern/chapter-15/
50. Lotus Sutra – Part 10, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.buddhistdoor.com/OldWeb/bdoor/0206/sources/lotus10.htm
51. “Realizing This World as the Buddha Land” (2009) – Princeton University, accessed April 9, 2025, https://www.princeton.edu/~jstone/Articles%20on%20the%20Lotus%20Sutra%20Tendai%20and%20Nichiren%20Buddhism/Realizing%20This%20World%20as%20the%20Buddha%20Land%20(2009).pdf